Towards a Reconsideration of Existing Interpretations Concerning the Small and Great Churches of Jvari

by meufeanania
0 comments

The architectural ensemble of the Jvari Monastery in Mtskheta is one of the most significant monuments of Georgian architecture. The Great Church of Jvari represents a classical example of a domed-cross church, in which the artistic solutions of both the interior and exterior are combined with exceptional perfection. The architect skillfully subordinated the composition of the façades to the natural surroundings and to the conditions of visual perception. The western façade, which is primarily visible from Mtskheta, is relatively restrained, whereas the eastern and southern façades contain the principal decorative program.

Of particular importance are the donor reliefs on the eastern façade depicting the Eristavis of Kartli—Stepanoz, Demetre, and Adarnase. These reliefs, together with their accompanying Asomtavruli inscriptions, constitute a major source for Georgian epigraphy and political history. The scene of the Exaltation of the Cross on the southern façade, as well as the kneeling figure on the drum of the dome, which some scholars identify as the architect of the church, belong among the finest examples of Georgian medieval sculpture.

A widely accepted view in scholarly literature holds that during the second half of the sixth century Guaram, Eristavi of Kartli, built a small church near the wooden Cross, while in the early seventh century his son Stepanoz I erected the Great Church of Jvari. This interpretation became especially influential through the works of Giorgi Chubinashvili and his school and continues to shape modern scholarship.

However, a renewed analysis of the written sources and architectural evidence allows for an alternative interpretation. The Kartlis Tskhovreba states that Guaram “began the construction of the Church of the Holy Cross” and completed it only partially. The text does not explicitly specify that this refers exclusively to the present Small Church. Consequently, this testimony may be understood as the beginning of a broader building process that ultimately resulted in the creation of the Great Church of Jvari.

At the same time, the architectural characteristics of the Small Church deserve particular attention. Its plan, dimensions, and composition indicate an important sanctuary, yet it is difficult to argue that it alone constituted the major and influential religious center associated with Mount Jvari in medieval sources. Therefore, serious consideration should be given to the possibility that the original structure was connected with the enclosure and architectural organization of the Holy Cross and that it gradually developed into a larger complex during subsequent stages.

According to the present study, the first stage in the architectural development of the wooden Cross on Mount Jvari may be connected with the activity of Prince Rev, when the Cross was enclosed within a domed structure. During a later period, this structure was enlarged and transformed into a church. One of the significant stages of construction may have been associated with Guaram Kuropalates, while the final completion appears to have taken place during the time of Stepanoz, Demetre, and Adarnase. In this case, the famous donor reliefs of the eastern façade would commemorate the completion of a building process extending across several generations.

This hypothesis differs from the established interpretations of Georgian art history. Nevertheless, it is based both on an alternative reading of the written sources and on a new understanding of the architectural forms. The question remains open and requires further investigation. Yet the available evidence allows us to view the construction of Jvari not as the history of two sharply separated churches, but rather as a single and prolonged creative process carried out over several generations.

From this perspective, the Great Church of Jvari may be regarded not merely as a completed monument of the early seventh century, but as the culmination of a multi-stage architectural development whose origins should be sought in a much earlier period.


Development of the Hypothesis: A Logical Sequence

  1. Saint Nino used an already existing non-Christian structure, located in the elite quarter of Mtskheta, for the baptism of the upper strata of early Christian Iberia—princes and nobles.

The upper classes of the Iberian capital were well acquainted with and adhered to the state religion of Sasanian Iran, namely the cult of sacred fire. Religious buildings of this tradition existed in Mtskheta, Tbilisi, and other centers, and some of their remains have survived to the present day. One such monument is the Ateshga, referred to in the Life of Saint Nino as the “Bagin.”

One such structure stood in the “Quarter of the Magi” in Mtskheta, near the Bridge of the Magi on the bank of the Mtkvari River. The very name of the district indicates the presence of numerous Magi—priests of the sacred fire. The area was regarded as a place of residence for the local elite. It was here that Saint Nino erected a Cross and used the structure as a baptistery for the nobility.

The Bagin, or Ateshga, was a square stone structure covered by a dome (a chahartaq), in the center of which a sacred fire burned upon a special platform. By the time of Saint Nino, however, it appears to have been functioning as a mausoleum. A Cross was erected above it—the first Cross raised by Saint Nino. The second Cross was established on the hill of Mtskheta, at the site where the Great Church of Jvari now stands.

This Cross erected by Saint Nino became known as the Holy Cross.

  • During the time of Saint Nino and King Mirian in the fourth century, only the Holy Cross stood upon the hill of Mtskheta, without any protective architectural structure.
  • For a certain period, the Cross remained exposed to the open air.
  • In fulfillment of a vow, Rev built a “cube” (kuba, gumbad) as a protective shelter for the Holy Cross—a dwelling place for the Cross. This was not yet a church in the later sense but rather a square stone structure surmounted by a dome, within which the Holy Cross stood upon a central platform.
  • The architectural form of this “cube” may have been related to the Sasanian chahartaq, already known in Kartli, similar to the structure upon which Saint Nino erected the first Cross in Bagin, in the Quarter of the Magi.
  • In the sixth century, Guaram Kuropalates used this earlier structure—the cube or gumbad—as the architectural core and began constructing around it a new and larger Christian church.
  • As a result, the Great Church of Jvari emerged as an architectural development and Christian transformation of Rev’s cube.
  • This process illustrates a principle of particular importance for the present study: Christianity did not completely reject local cultic architectural forms but rather reinterpreted and transformed them.

In this regard, the parallel between Saint Nino’s transformation of the space of Bagin into a Christian sacred space and the subsequent development of Jvari architecture is especially significant. If this approach is accepted, the Georgian centrally domed church may be understood not as a wholly imported form but as the result of the Christian transformation of local and Irano-Georgian architectural traditions.

One of the strengths of this hypothesis lies in the fact that the Conversion of Kartli first mentions a “gumbad,” whereas several centuries later we encounter the completed Great Church of Jvari. This gives rise to an important research question:

Was Rev’s gumbad merely a small protective structure, or did it already constitute the nucleus of the monumental composition that would later develop into the Great Church of Jvari?

The gumbad, or cube, of Rev was probably a tall square-plan structure. Its height would have been determined by the dimensions of the tree from which the Holy Cross was carved. According to the source, three crosses were made from a single large tree: the largest was erected on the hill of Mtskheta, the second, somewhat smaller, on Mount Tkhoti, and the third in the Udjarma–Bodbe region.

The considerable height of the Holy Cross is also suggested by the structure that survives to this day at the center of the Great Church of Jvari and once served as the pedestal of the Cross. It is a large and monumental construction. Upon it stood the Cross of Saint Nino, the principal shrine of the church.

Consequently, the tall Cross erected on the hill of Mtskheta was enclosed within a stone domed structure—a cube. This structure was later enlarged by Guaram Kuropalates and his descendants and eventually consecrated as a fully developed church by Catholicos Kyrion, the champion of Chalcedonian orthodoxy.

Because the church was consecrated by Catholicos Kyrion, who actively opposed Monophysitism, it came to be regarded as a Chalcedonian sanctuary. For this reason, according to the Book of Letters and other sources, the Armenian Catholicos prohibited Armenian Monophysites (Miaphysites) from visiting and venerating this church.

As a result, the architectural form of the Great Church of Jvari gradually became a symbol of the Chalcedonian faith. Subsequently, Orthodox Christians in Georgia and neighboring regions built churches modeled upon this prototype, which became one of the most important architectural expressions of Chalcedonian ecclesiastical identity.

Development of the Hypothesis: A Proposed Interpretative Framework

The present hypothesis may be outlined through the following sequence of arguments, which are offered as a possible interpretation of the available textual and architectural evidence rather than as definitive historical conclusions.

  1. It may be suggested that Saint Nino employed an already existing non-Christian structure, located within an elite district of Mtskheta, for the baptism of members of the upper social strata of early Christian Iberia.

The aristocracy of late antique Kartli appears to have been familiar with, and to varying degrees influenced by, the religious traditions associated with Sasanian Iran, particularly the cult of sacred fire. Archaeological and literary evidence indicates the existence of such cultic structures in Mtskheta, Tbilisi, and other urban centers. One of these may be identified with the structure referred to in the hagiographical tradition as “Bagin” or Ateshga.

According to this interpretation, a structure of this type may have existed in the so-called “Quarter of the Magi” in Mtskheta. If so, Saint Nino’s erection of a Cross in this location could be understood as an example of the Christian appropriation and transformation of an existing sacred space.

  • The available sources suggest that during the time of Saint Nino and King Mirian in the fourth century, the Holy Cross stood upon the hill of Mtskheta without a permanent architectural enclosure.
  • It is possible that the Cross remained exposed for a certain period before any substantial protective structure was erected around it.
  • The references to a gumbad in the written tradition may indicate that Prince Rev fulfilled his vow by constructing a domed structure intended to protect and monumentalize the Holy Cross. Such a building need not necessarily be understood as a church in the later architectural sense but may instead have represented a commemorative or cultic shelter centred upon the Cross itself.
  • The architectural form of this structure may have been influenced by the chahartaq type known from the Sasanian cultural sphere and already familiar in Kartli. Such a possibility would deserve consideration in light of the broader processes of cultural and architectural interaction occurring in Late Antiquity.
  • If this interpretation is accepted, the structure attributed to Rev may have served as the architectural nucleus around which Guaram Kuropalates initiated a more ambitious programme of church construction during the sixth century.
  • The Great Church of Jvari could therefore be viewed not as an entirely new foundation, but rather as the result of a gradual architectural expansion and Christian reinterpretation of an earlier sacred structure.
  • This line of interpretation highlights a broader phenomenon that may have characterized the Christianization of Kartli: the adaptation and transformation of pre-existing sacred architectural forms rather than their complete rejection.

From this perspective, the relationship between Saint Nino’s transformation of the sacred space of Bagin and the subsequent architectural development of Jvari acquires particular significance. The Georgian centrally domed church may thus be understood, at least in part, as the outcome of a complex process through which local and Irano-Georgian architectural traditions were reinterpreted within a Christian framework.

One of the most intriguing aspects of this hypothesis is the chronological sequence preserved in the written sources. The Conversion of Kartli mentions a gumbad, whereas several centuries later the historical record presents the fully developed Great Church of Jvari. This raises an important research question:

Should Rev’s gumbad be understood merely as a modest protective structure, or might it already have constituted the architectural core from which the later monumental composition of Jvari ultimately evolved?

Although a definitive answer remains elusive, several observations may be noted. The gumbad attributed to Rev may have been a relatively substantial structure whose dimensions were conditioned by the height of the Holy Cross itself. The sources indicate that three crosses were fashioned from a single large tree, the largest being erected on the hill of Mtskheta. Furthermore, the monumental pedestal preserved within the Great Church of Jvari suggests that the Cross occupied a position of exceptional prominence within the sacred complex.

On this basis, it may be proposed that the Holy Cross was at some stage enclosed within a domed stone structure, which subsequently underwent expansion and architectural transformation. Guaram Kuropalates and his successors may have played a decisive role in this process, while the final completion of the monument appears to belong to the period associated with Stepanoz, Demetre, and Adarnase.

The consecration of the church by Catholicos Kyrion, a leading defender of Chalcedonian orthodoxy, further suggests that the sanctuary acquired a distinct Chalcedonian identity. The evidence preserved in the Book of Letters and related sources indicates that this identity was sufficiently pronounced to influence ecclesiastical relations with the Armenian Church.

Within such a framework, the architectural form of the Great Church of Jvari may be interpreted not only as a masterpiece of Georgian architecture but also as a visual expression of Chalcedonian ecclesiastical self-definition. Its influence on subsequent church architecture in Georgia and neighbouring regions may therefore reflect both architectural and confessional continuity.

Naturally, this reconstruction remains hypothetical. Further archaeological, architectural, and textual investigation will be necessary in order to evaluate its validity. Nevertheless, the available evidence appears sufficient to justify reconsideration of the traditional model and to explore the possibility that the history of Jvari was characterized by a long and continuous process of architectural development extending across several generations.

You may also like

Leave a Comment